A Candid Conversation on Faith, Politics, and Evangelicalism

In a thoughtful discussion hosted by Theology Lab, journalist David Brooks and theologian Jim Wallis explore the intersection of faith and public life. Moderated by Walter Kim, the conversation dives into how their personal journeys shaped their religious and political views, and what the church’s role should be in today’s divided society.

Personal Journeys into Faith

Jim Wallis shared how his early evangelical upbringing clashed with the racism he witnessed in Detroit. When his church told him racism had “nothing to do with faith,” he left in disillusionment—but couldn’t shake his connection to Jesus. His faith evolved to be deeply personal but also unapologetically public, centered around justice and care for the marginalized.

David Brooks described growing up in a Jewish home but attending an Episcopal school, eventually becoming a Christian in midlife. While his faith journey was personal, it didn’t drastically change his politics. Instead, his belief in the dignity of each person was deepened by Christianity, reinforcing values he already held.

Faith and Political Engagement

Both speakers agreed: faith should inform political engagement—but not be co-opted by it. Wallis emphasized that a Christian’s primary political responsibility is to advocate for “the least of these,” echoing Jesus’ words in Matthew 25. Brooks highlighted the danger of letting politics become a substitute for moral formation, warning that it can offer the illusion of community and purpose without requiring self-reflection or sacrifice.

The Usurping of Religion by Politics

The panel warned that in many communities, politics has overtaken religion as the source of identity and morality. Brooks pointed out that politics often simplifies complex human struggles into “us vs. them” battles. Wallis added that when churches merely reflect political demographics, they lose their theological distinctiveness and risk becoming echo chambers.

The Church’s Role in a Divided Society

The speakers offered a vision for how the church can heal political and social divides. Brooks emphasized the importance of everyday kindness and moral attentiveness in shaping character. Wallis called for churches to be bold truth-tellers and spaces where people of all backgrounds can discuss and address community issues.

Engaging the Next Generation

Both panelists expressed hope in younger Christians. Wallis noted that students are hungry for the true message of the gospel, especially teachings centered on justice and dignity. Brooks encouraged young believers not to shy away from their faith, but to recognize they possess spiritual resources the world desperately needs.

Guiding Principles for Faith in Public Life

As a final takeaway, both Brooks and Wallis urged believers to hold fast to the unchanging truths of their faith while staying flexible in political application. They stressed that Christian political engagement should be measured not by tribal loyalty, but by how well it serves the vulnerable and fosters human dignity.